People say you shouldn’t judge a book by its cover, but we all know that’s not true. Based upon this title, was it not evident that this site was going to be two bitches talking about something (hopefully it didn’t take long for you to realize what we were talking about…Theatre!)? When you read the title of this blog, the choice was yours whether or not you wanted to read it. So all 783 of you didn’t have to actually read this blog. Oh and we actually are technically considered to be professional theatrical people, and we, in real life, have extensive credits for theatre both on and off-stage (just for the record).
So what was this whole thing about? Was it just to rip on the shows, especially the ones at schools that we have a supposed “rivalry” with? Was it because we were bored and have nothing better to do with our lives besides sit at our computer? Was it because we were smoking something? Was it because we are just plain mean? Why?
Congratulations, you’ve officially been part of a social experiment. There were two purposes for this blog, the first of which being to critique the critics in a playful way and the second being a wake-up call to those that want to go into the theater world but aren’t prepared to take the criticism that comes with it. Critics often rip shows apart, like we have done in this blog, and fail to see the artistic value and the positive aspects of each show. They don’t relate other outstanding factors to the success of a high school’s show (i.e. newness of campus, talent pool, etc.). Instead they just say the harshest comments possible for shock value. We never said anything that wasn’t true, although we did exaggerate it. In contrast, those that participated in the show should also have the maturity and mental acumen to realize that every critic is going to have their own opinion and rebuking it as you have done only shows your immaturity in the situation. If you can’t handle the heat, get out of the kitchen! This is high school theater, not your third grade soccer team. Your show is going to be bad mouthed and rather than becoming a hot mess, it would be much better advised to take the criticism with a grain of salt and move on with your life. If you want to work in the theater industry and just gave a gut response on this blog: Congratulations! You will never succeed.
And just one last note, if you took this blog personally you really shouldn’t have. You may have only read the blog about your school, but if you took the next few seconds to read the other few reviews you would have become quickly aware that we didn’t write practically anything positive about any show. So don’t take this too seriously.
When we started writing this blog, we had no intention of making it anything more than a funny site for people to read and laugh at. What you all ended up posting and telling us, or people we know, was far crazier than we expected. A lot of people took it way to seriously, when you don’t even know us, why do you care so much about our opinion and what we wrote? It’s not our job to police you and how you handle criticism, but when you chose to read this blog, you decided to become a part of this whole “social experiment” and that was your choice. If you are serious about the art and fighting for what the very essence of theatre is, then take this as a quick warning about what you are personally immature about and need to work on for when times like this come up in your own professional career.
So in the next few weeks we will be reviewing a few shows. When you read them, take a moment to realize the absurd qualities instead of just getting upset. When you take this attitude, you may even chuckle about some of the things we wrote.
We couldn’t help ourselves, below is Faye and Finny’s responses to the comments you all posted:
Finny: To “Leather baybeh”. Your name is dis-turb-ing. And a course you ain’t seen my ass on a stage! This shit is ANONYMOUS. See I can capitalize shit too! For all you know you’ve seen me on stage and said I was the best thing your eyes had ever seen!
Finny: To “hayleeanne”. DID YOU JUST SPELL THESPIANS WRONG? AH HELLL TO THE NAH. THIS DID NOT JUST OH-CCUR! Gurl get yo’self to a dictionary! And can you read? I did not say that she was “too mean” or nothing like that. I said that she was a terrible actress and didn’t have a cohesive character. B’okay I don’t remember if I said that, but I implied it!
Finny: And for all the haters talking all up in my grill about budget cuts: yeah we know bitches. We had budget cuts too. But I know for a fact that other schools will let you borrow costumes if they’re not using em and if you live your life talking out of your ass through excuses, bitches and hoes: you ain’t going NOWHERE. Where there’s a will, there is a damn way.
Finny: To “KC” and “beentherebefore”. If I am not worth it, then why did you spend it? If you like it then you shoulda put a ring on it bitches!
Faye: To “Bob Stanislavski Broke My Heart” Thank you for taking this in the way it was meant. Gold star for you sugar!
Faye: To “Heather”, First off, are you kidding me? Her name isn’t Ann, it’s Anne. I can tell you’ve done your research *sarcasm*…Anyways, the only thing I said was “And Anne stop pretending to be awkward and sad (how sad that I can’t even call it acting, but instead pretending)!”. I didn’t attack her portrayal of the character, I attacked her acting technique. If you can’t recognize “pretending” vs. “acting” you might want to go see a good show sometime and then compare. It’s really evident when people are pretending. And you might find this funny, but I already did the show and a heck of a lot of research for my part. So honey, I guarantee I know this show better than you.
Faye: To “Tac”, honey, I am diggin’ your name and that you want to stand up for your friends. Let me help you, people who write reviews on shows are called Critics (here’s the phonetic spelling if you need help: krit-ik. And feel free to look up the definition, hint: it has something to do with criticizing). I don’t sit on the computer all day, and even if I did why the heck do you care? You’re apparently on the computer too. Reality check: the show wasn’t great and I do have a life. Enjoy yours and I’ll enjoy mine.
Faye: To “Megan”, I LOL-ED at that! Thank you so much!! You made that review worth writing.
Faye: To “Peyton Geery”, thanks for the props on our writing ability, love ya boo! I am so happy that you got it! I know you and have a lot more respect for you and your opinion now. You honestly surprised me and to a certain extent I agree with you, but it was all in how people chose to react to this blog. Keep following us bitches.
Faye: To “Spenser” (Cinderella), love your name it makes me think of Spenser and Heidi Montag, otherwise known as “Spidi” J Watch The Hills bro! Here is a thought: DO A LESS EXPENSIVE SHOW or find areas to cut production costs. Think about it, you may have got more people by charging less. And Cheers? I hope you aren’t drinking yet, you’re in high school therefore not legal.
Faye: To “Spenser” (Secret Garden) Back again? As already stated we don’t state any of the positives so you may have liked the show. But now you’ll never know. And I believe someone has been talking to Ms. Vines about the accent thing. But I liked that you tried to play it off you look you were so researched and educated haha However, if you listen to an Irish accent tape and a Yorkshire accent tape, they sound different in many ways. We ripped on everything we could, so take a chill.
Faye: To “Bryttani”, that’s weird, because I am a professional. Guess I am right. Pointing out the positive would defeat the purpose and yes, we are like most critics (on purpose…). I don’t have any problem with the first part of this comment. It’s the part about seeing it on “bad day”. High school theatres should strive to be professional, do you think professional theatres ever get a break from putting on their best show yet? Heck no! If it was a bad day then I question your very philosophy of what exactly theatre is about. Oh and I am still deciding if the last part of the comment is jealousy that the stepmother was actually almost a positive part of the show.
Faye: To “Wiiiiiskaaaay”, I know it was Finny’s article that got all the comments on grammar, but you should know that we both have taken college English courses and are probably way ahead of you. Perhaps you are confusing our personas with our actual selves.
Faye: To “Rachel Rice”, I like the foxy alliteration in your name. Anyways, we mentioned everything because that’s the point of this blog. There you go. And the singing was not fine, quite literally, it was NOT GOOD. And a school full of mini Justin Timberlakes would be frighteningly terrible too, so no thank you to that. Funny, that you ask me to “Get up on a stage with a money budget & a lot of kids to direct…” because I actually just did that. So yes, on a scale of 1-10 I get it on a 20. You’re Welcome!
Faye: To “Leather baybeh” Already in college, wayyyy ahead of you sista’/bro (idk?).
Faye: To “Stune Choppa” LOVE YOU!
Faye: To “hayleeanne” did you play Cinderella’s stepmother? Im just curious because of your valiant sticking-up for whoever played her…I don’t really care, I was just wondering, because of all the things Finny picked on in that review that was the least of the show’s worries. Oh and note to you: THESPIAN…haha that made me laugh like nuts I honestly hope you aren’t part of the society yet. Were all those people in the show International Thespian Society members? They need to be evicted if so, because there were definitely some people who should not have been inducted. Not everyone though.
Faye: To “beentherebefore”, the point of theatre is to not only accept the praise but also the criticism that helps to make performances better. If you only take one side of the coin you’ll never be successful. Unless if you are perfect….then you need more help than I am willing to write. Oh and fyi, I don’t need someone to critique me harshly because I already am my own worst critique if anyone can out-critique me, then they are doing a social experiment blog
Faye: To “KC”, I flippin’ love your fake email address! Don’t worry, it’s not we would ever email a hater.
Faye: To “beentherebefore” (2nd comment), welcome back. Why revisit the site if it’s not worth your time or energy? You’re a funny kid. I like you already. Oh, but we are not better than everyone else we just critique harder than anyone would to people’s faces.
SO those are all the comments we wanted to respond to, which was pretty much all of them. Thanks so much for writing and commenting (even if most of you are haters, we still love you!) Keep em’ coming! Thank you! And as we say in our “About You” Mission Statement-y Thing:
We are two flamboyant ass bitches critiquing the high school plays and musicals from around the phoenix metro area. We are harsh. Get over it.